The Modesty Mirror Test: Is Your Outfit Still Modest When You Move?
Share
The Modest & Devoted Wardrobe Check — Part 1
Stand • Sit • Reach • Bend • Walk • Turn
Have you ever gotten completely dressed, looked in the mirror and thought, Yes. This works.
The neckline is covered. The skirt is long enough. The fit looks appropriate. You're ready to walk out the door.
But then you actually start living in your clothes.
You sit down. You reach for something on a shelf. You bend over to pick up a child. You walk up a flight of stairs.
And suddenly that outfit doesn't behave quite the way it did when you were standing perfectly still in front of the mirror.
That's why I believe one of the most useful questions we can ask about an outfit is not simply, “Is this modest?”
Instead, let's ask: “Does this outfit stay modest when I move?”
Welcome to the first installment of The Modest & Devoted Wardrobe Check, a series about approaching our clothing thoughtfully, practically and—most importantly—with a heart that desires to honor God.
Modesty Is More Than a Measurement
There are certainly practical standards that help us choose clothing wisely. Length matters. Necklines matter. Sleeves matter. Coverage matters.
But modesty can't always be determined with a measuring tape.
Years ago, I was influenced by the modesty teachings of Christian author and Bible teacher Nancy DeMoss Wolgemuth. One thing I especially appreciate about Nancy's approach is her encouragement for women to think about their clothing rather than simply follow a list of rules.
In her teaching on modesty, Nancy has encouraged women to consider what happens to their clothing when they walk, climb stairs, bend over or reach for something. She has also challenged women to consider not only what clothing exposes, but what it emphasizes.
That distinction has stayed with me.
Because an outfit doesn't live on a hanger. And we don't spend our lives standing perfectly still in front of a mirror.
We move. So let's move in front of the mirror, too.
The Modest & Devoted Mirror Test
Before deciding that an outfit works, put on the entire outfit—including the undergarments and layering pieces you plan to wear with it. Then find a full-length mirror.
Don't pose. Don't arrange the fabric perfectly. Just move the way you will move during an ordinary day.
Then do six things:
1. STAND
Stand naturally in front of the mirror and look at the entire outfit. Ask yourself: Does everything provide the coverage I intended? Is anything unusually tight? Is the fabric clinging somewhere I didn't notice on the hanger? Does it become sheer when stretched? Where does the eye naturally go?
Nancy DeMoss Wolgemuth has encouraged women to consider that last question specifically. That's different from simply asking whether everything is technically covered.
Modesty isn't only about exposure. We should think about emphasis, too.
2. SIT
Now sit down. Really.
A skirt or dress that provides plenty of coverage while standing can behave very differently once you're seated. Does the hemline rise substantially? Does a slit open? Does fabric suddenly pull tightly across your hips or thighs? Do buttons begin to gap? Does the neckline shift?
If you're going to spend part of your day sitting, then the seated version of your outfit is part of the outfit.
3. REACH
Raise both arms. Reach forward. Reach overhead as though you're getting something from a high shelf.
Did your shirt rise and expose your waist? Did the bodice pull tighter? Did raising your arms change the neckline? Did your sleeves shift farther than expected?
Something can look perfectly appropriate with our arms resting at our sides and look completely different once we reach.
4. BEND
This may be the most revealing part of the test. Lean forward, then bend farther—as though you're picking something up from the floor.
Look at your neckline. Does it stay where you thought it would?
A neckline can appear perfectly modest while we're standing upright and then fall several inches away from the body when we lean forward. Loose and flowy clothing can sometimes create this problem precisely because it isn't tight.
Loose doesn't automatically mean modest, just as covered doesn't automatically mean modest. The question is how the garment behaves on your body.
5. WALK
Take several normal steps. Turn around and walk back. If you're wearing a skirt or dress, watch the hem and any openings.
Does a slit open considerably farther while moving? Does a wrap separate? Does fabric cling as you walk? Does a lightweight skirt become more revealing in motion than while standing still?
And here's a practical one for skirt-loving ladies: What happens when there's a breeze? We've probably all learned that lesson at least once!
Clothing moves because we move. Our modesty check should account for that.
6. TURN
Finally, turn around. Look at yourself from the side, then from behind.
This isn't about criticizing your body. It's about remembering something simple: Other people don't only see us from the front.
Does the garment fit differently across the bust from the side? Does fabric pull across the hips or backside? Does a shirt that appears long enough from the front rise significantly in the back? Is something sheer under the room's lighting that you didn't notice initially?
The goal isn't to scrutinize ourselves into insecurity. The goal is simply to see the whole outfit.
What If an Outfit Fails the Test?
Here's where I want The Modest & Devoted Wardrobe Check to be different.
The answer isn't always: “You can't wear that.”
Sometimes the answer is: “How can I make this work?”
Maybe that beautiful dress needs a simple layering top underneath. Maybe the neckline needs a camisole. Maybe a lightweight dress needs a slip. Maybe adding a cardigan solves the issue. Maybe sizing up gives the garment the drape you originally wanted.
And sometimes, yes, we may decide that a particular garment simply isn't right for us. That's okay, too.
Modesty doesn't have to make getting dressed miserable.
At ModestAndDevoted, one of the reasons we love good layering pieces is that they can open up possibilities in your wardrobe. A simple long-sleeve layering top with a modest neckline can turn a dress or jumper that wasn't quite workable into something beautiful, comfortable and useful.
Be comfy. Be beautiful. Be modest.
Those things don't have to compete with one another.
But Before the Mirror Comes the Heart
There is one part of Nancy DeMoss Wolgemuth's teaching that I don't want us to lose while we're talking about practical wardrobe checks: modesty begins in the heart.
Because if this series becomes nothing more than another checklist of rules—another way for women to compare themselves with other women—we've missed the point.
First Timothy 2:9 speaks of women adorning themselves in respectable apparel, with modesty and self-control. And 1 Peter 5:5 tells believers to clothe themselves with humility.
Before I ask, Is my skirt long enough? Is my neckline high enough? Does this blouse fit correctly? there is a deeper question:
What does my clothing choice say about the desires of my heart?
Am I seeking attention? Am I dressing primarily for the approval of others? Or am I trying to live—including in something as ordinary as getting dressed—in a way that reflects my devotion to God?
Those aren't questions I can answer for you. They're questions each of us can prayerfully ask ourselves.
And I think that's a much healthier approach to modesty than constantly looking at the woman beside us and deciding whether she passes our test.
Try the Mirror Test Tomorrow
Tomorrow morning, before you leave home, take an extra two minutes.
Remember these six words:
STAND • SIT • REACH • BEND • WALK • TURN
Don't just ask whether your outfit looks modest while you're standing still. See what happens when you live in it.
You may discover an outfit works beautifully. You may discover that one little layering piece solves a problem. And occasionally you may look in the mirror, laugh and say, Well... I'm glad I checked that before I left the house.
I've been there too. That's exactly why we're doing this together.
The Modest & Devoted Wardrobe Check
This article is Part 1 of an ongoing ModestAndDevoted series exploring practical, biblical modesty for real life.
Coming next: Part 2 — Covered Doesn't Always Mean Modest: Exposure vs. Emphasis
We'll talk about something that changed the way I evaluate clothing: A garment can cover the body and still emphasize it. We'll look at fit, cling, fabric, seams and drape—and why “Is everything covered?” sometimes isn't enough.
A Note About Our Inspiration
This series is original content from ModestAndDevoted, developed from our own experiences dressing, shopping for, selling and helping women find modest clothing.
Some principles discussed in this series have also been influenced by the teaching of Nancy DeMoss Wolgemuth, whose ministry has addressed biblical modesty extensively. Her Revive Our Hearts resources include Exposing and Emphasizing, A Modest Heart, and other teachings on thoughtful, biblical modesty.
We are grateful for women who encourage other women to think biblically and intentionally about modesty.
— Stephanie & the ModestAndDevoted Family
Be comfy. Be beautiful. Be modest.
ModestAndDevoted • Grenada, Mississippi